
The Google September 2022 product reviews update started on 20 September 2022 and finished on 26 September 2022, a six-day rollout that again rewarded English-language review content with real analysis over templated summaries. Its awkward feature was timing: it landed during the final week of the September 2022 core update, so many review sites saw two sets of changes at once. If your review pages moved that week, the job is to work out which update was responsible before you change anything.
This article is part of my full list of Google algorithm updates, where each entry is written from confirmed sources rather than forum rumour.
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Update name | Google September 2022 product reviews update |
| Type | Reviews (product reviews system) |
| Rollout started | 20 September 2022 (around 4am ET) |
| Rollout finished | 26 September 2022 |
| Rollout length | 6 days |
| Confirmed by Google | Yes, announced and marked complete by Google |
| Official source | Google Search Status Dashboard ranking history |
What the September 2022 product reviews update changed
This was the fifth product reviews update. The earlier ones came in April 2021, December 2021, March 2022 and July 2022, so by September 2022 the direction was well established. Google said the aim was to reward “review content that is above and beyond much of the templated information you see on the web”.
In practice, the product reviews system looks at pages whose job is to recommend or evaluate products: “best X” round-ups, single-product reviews and comparison pieces. It was still limited to English, with Google promising more languages later. It did not target product pages with customer reviews on them; it was about editorial review content.
The phrase “templated information” is the key. A large share of affiliate review content at the time followed the same pattern: an intro, a specification table copied from the manufacturer, a list of features restated as benefits, a generic pros and cons box and a buy button. Each update in the series pushed further against that pattern and towards pages showing that someone had actually used, measured or compared the products.
Timeline
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| 12 September 2022 | September 2022 core update begins (around 11:26am ET) |
| 20 September 2022 | Product reviews update begins around 4am ET |
| 26 September 2022 | Google confirms both the product reviews update and the core update are complete |
The overlap is why this update is hard to read in hindsight. Every day of the reviews rollout also fell inside the core update window, and both finished on the same day.
Previous product reviews updates
- April 2021: first product reviews update
- December 2021: second
- March 2022: third
- July 2022: fourth
- September 2022: fifth (this one)
Traffic fell off a cliff?
Find out if an update is to blame and what to fix first.
Who was affected
Review publishers and affiliate sites moved, as they did with each reviews update. Search Engine Land reported that the overlap with the September core update made the cause of individual movements difficult to isolate. I have not seen reliable published data on the size of the swings for this specific update, so I will not quote numbers.
The types of site most exposed were English-language affiliate blogs built around “best” lists, niche review sites covering many unrelated product categories, and larger publishers with commerce sections written at volume.
How to tell if the September 2022 product reviews update hit your site
Because two updates overlapped, the diagnosis here is mainly about separating them. This is the method I use.
- Pick clean comparison windows. In Search Console, compare roughly 30 August to 11 September 2022 (before the core update began) with 27 September to 10 October 2022 (after both had finished). Then look at the daily chart for the change in slope.
- Split by page type. Filter the Pages report by URL pattern, for example
/best-,/reviewor your review category folder. Then do the same for informational guides, news and category pages. - Read the result. If losses are concentrated on review pages and your guides held steady, the reviews update is the likely cause. If everything moved by a similar amount, the core update is the more likely explanation.
- Look at the daily shape. A step change starting 12 to 14 September points to the core update. A change starting 20 to 22 September, mainly on review URLs, points to the reviews update.
- Rule out the usual suspects. Check analytics tagging, any template or site changes made that month, seasonal demand (September often has back-to-school and pre-holiday shifts in product searches) and lost featured snippets.
How to recover from the September 2022 product reviews update
Google’s advice for every product reviews update has been consistent: provide insightful analysis, original research and evidence of expertise. Recovery is evaluated at the next reviews update, so the work you do now is judged later, not overnight.
Step 1: Audit your review pages honestly
Open your top 20 losing review URLs side by side with the pages that now outrank you. Ask what the winning page shows that yours does not: photos you took, test results, measurements, a clear verdict for a named type of buyer, or comparisons with alternatives.
Step 2: Replace templated sections with evidence
| Templated pattern | What to replace it with |
|---|---|
| Manufacturer spec table | Specs you checked, plus what they mean in use |
| Generic pros and cons | Pros and cons tied to a specific test or situation |
| Stock product images | Your own photos or video of the product in use |
| “Best overall” with no reason | A verdict that names who should buy it and who should not |
| One affiliate link | Links to more than one seller where that helps the reader |
Step 3: Show who did the testing
Add author information that explains the person’s relevant experience, and describe how products were chosen and tested. A short methodology section on each round-up is often enough.
Step 4: Prune or merge what you cannot improve
If you have dozens of thin “best” pages in categories you have never tested, either rewrite them properly or remove them. Ten reviews with real evidence will do more than a hundred rewritten listings.
Step 5: Fix the basics on review templates
Make sure review pages load quickly and do not bury the verdict under ads. If your templates need work, my on-page optimisation service covers layout, headings and internal linking for review content.
Step 6: Wait for the next reviews update
Changes are usually assessed when the reviews system runs again. Keep improving pages rather than making one change and waiting to see if it worked.
Is it still relevant today?
The principles are. Google later renamed the product reviews system to the reviews system and broadened it beyond products, and the standalone reviews updates eventually stopped being announced separately. The core idea of the September 2022 update, that review content should prove experience instead of restating specifications, is still how I assess any review page today.
Frequently asked questions
When was the September 2022 product reviews update?
It started around 4am ET on 20 September 2022 and Google confirmed it was complete on 26 September 2022, a six-day rollout.
Was the September 2022 product reviews update the same as the core update?
No. They were separate updates, but they overlapped. The core update ran from 12 to 26 September 2022 and the reviews update from 20 to 26 September, so the whole reviews rollout sat inside the core update window.
Did the September 2022 product reviews update affect non-English sites?
It was English only. Google said more languages would follow, and that expansion came with the February 2023 product reviews update.
How long does recovery take after a product reviews update?
Usually until the next time the reviews system is updated, as that is when improved pages are reassessed. There is no fixed timeline.
Sources
- Google Search Status Dashboard
- Search Engine Land: release announcement
- Search Engine Land: rollout complete
- Keywords Everywhere
If your review pages lost traffic in late September 2022 and you are still not sure whether the core update or the reviews update was to blame, I can look at your data and tell you. Request a free audit, or see what my SEO audit service covers.
Request received
Thank you! Saad will contact you within the next 24 hours.
Keep an eye on your phone and inbox.
More Google algorithm updates
- Previous update: September 2022 Core Update (12 Sep 2022)
- Next update: October 2022 Spam Update (19 Oct 2022)
Other reviews updates:
- Product Reviews Update (July 2022) (27 Jul 2022)
- Product Reviews Update (March 2022) (23 Mar 2022)
- Product Reviews Update (December 2021) (1 Dec 2021)
- Product Reviews Update (February 2023) (21 Feb 2023)
